Broadband from the tops Queensbury & Thornton · BD13 01274 000000

Blog · Comparison

Wireless, fibre, 5G or satellite: which fits?

Six ways to get broadband into a house on the tops, what each one is good at, and where each one falls down.

Queensbury from the fields, with the Black Dyke Mills chimney — Tim Green, CC BY 2.0

On the high ground west of Bradford, the broadband on offer can change from one street to the next. One terrace has full fibre, the farm half a mile further on is stuck on a long copper line, and the house in between gets a strong 5G signal upstairs and nothing in the kitchen. What matters is which types can reach your address, and which of those suits your household.

Full fibre (FTTP)

Full fibre runs a fibre-optic cable all the way into your home. Light travelling through glass loses very little strength over distance, so your speed does not depend on how far you live from the exchange or the street cabinet. It is the fastest and steadiest option there is, usually sold at anything from around 100Mbps to 1Gbps or more.

The catch is availability. Scattered properties at the end of long lanes are the most expensive ones to reach with new cable. Coverage on the tops is patchy, so check your own address before assuming either way. If full fibre is live where you are, it is usually the right answer.

Part fibre (FTTC)

Much of what has been sold as "fibre broadband" over the years is really fibre to the cabinet. The fibre stops at the green cabinet on the street and your copper phone line covers the rest. Close to the cabinet it can reach around 80Mbps. The further away you are, the slower it gets, and at the end of a long line it may be little better than the older ADSL service. We have written a separate guide to why copper slows down with distance.

Cable

Virgin Media's cable network uses its own cabling instead of phone lines and offers very high top speeds. It is only available on roads where that network has been laid.

Fixed wireless

Fixed wireless swaps the cable to your home for a radio link. A small aerial on your roof or chimney points at a mast on high ground, and the mast is connected to a fibre backbone. This is what we do at Scarlet Heights.

Its strength is that distance from the cabinet stops mattering. If your aerial can see the mast, you get the full connection whether you are in the village centre or at the end of the lane. Its limit is that it needs line of sight. A hill, a belt of tall trees or a neighbour's gable end in the way can rule an address out, which is why a survey comes first.

Speeds and prices vary a good deal from one wireless provider to another. Ours is a single package: Heights 10, 10Mbps for £15 a month with a one-off £200 set-up, no phone line and no data caps. The pricing page has the details.

4G and 5G home broadband

This is a router with a SIM card inside, using the same mobile networks as your phone. There is no engineer visit, so it can be working within days, and where the signal is strong the speeds can be very good.

The weak points are consistency and indoor signal. A mobile mast shares its capacity between everyone using it, so speeds often dip in the evening when the network is busy. Thick stone walls weaken the signal indoors. Before committing to a long contract, put a SIM from the same network in a phone and run speed tests in the room where the router would live, at different times of day.

Satellite

Satellite reaches almost anywhere with a clear view of the sky, which makes it the fallback for properties nothing else can reach. Older services use geostationary satellites around 36,000km above the equator. The signal takes long enough to make the round trip that there is a delay of half a second or more, which makes video calls awkward and fast online games close to unplayable. Newer low-earth-orbit services such as Starlink use satellites only a few hundred kilometres up, which cuts that delay dramatically and allows much higher speeds.

The trade-offs are cost and practicalities. Satellite often costs more than a typical fixed-line deal once the dish is included, the dish needs an unobstructed view of a wide patch of sky, and very heavy rain or snow can affect the signal.

Side by side

TypeDepends onGood forWatch out for
Full fibreWhether it has reached your addressEverything, including busy householdsPatchy availability on the tops
Part fibreLength of copper from the cabinetHomes close to the cabinetLong lines get a fraction of the headline speed
CableWhether your road has been cabledVery high speedsLimited to cabled streets
Fixed wirelessA clear line of sight to the mastLong copper lines with a view of high groundNeeds a survey and a rooftop aerial
4G / 5GSignal strength and how busy the mast isGetting online quickly with no engineerSpeeds vary through the day; weak behind stone walls
SatelliteA clear view of the skyProperties nothing else reachesCost, and delay on older geostationary services

How to choose

  1. Check your exact address, not the postcode. Availability and speed estimates only mean something at address level.
  2. If full fibre is there, start with it. Look at the price after any introductory term, not only the headline.
  3. If it is not, find out what your copper line really delivers and weigh that against the wireless and mobile options.
  4. Match it to your household. Our guide to how much speed you need walks through the sums.
  5. Compare the whole cost. Add the set-up fee to the monthly price over two or three years. The calculator on our pricing page does this for our package against your current bill.

If you live in Queensbury and Thornton, the postcode check gives an indicative answer in a few seconds, and a free survey confirms whether your roof can see one of our masts. If it cannot, or another type of connection would suit you better, the other providers page lists the main alternatives.

Keep reading

More from the blog

Can we see your roof?

Check your postcode

Pop in your postcode for an instant indicative check, then we'll confirm with a free survey.

Looking across Thornton from the top of the viaduct — Tim Green, CC BY 2.0